1996-06-13 – Stanton Friedman, Richard Berendzen – Space Travel, Roswell, UFOs

Show: Coast To Coast AM

Air Date: June 16, 1996

Guest(s): Stanton Friedman, Richard Berendzen

Topic(s): Space Travel, Roswell, UFOs

Art introduces Berendzen, highlighting his extensive background and achievements in the fields of science and education. Berendzen’s career spans various roles, including a staff scientist at the Geophysics Corporation of America, a lecturer and acting chairman at Boston University, and a consultant to numerous scientific organizations. The conversation then shifts to another guest, Stanton Friedman, a physicist who recently returned from Brazil and is scheduled to speak on the show later. Art also mentions a scientific report related to Roswell, with detailed analyses available on his website. The segment concludes with a discussion between Art and Berendzen about light pollution and its impact on our ability to observe the night sky, emphasizing the awe-inspiring nature of the Milky Way as viewed from less light-polluted areas.

Art Bell and his guest Richard Berendzen delve deeper into the realm of space exploration and the limitations imposed by the laws of physics, particularly the speed of light. They discuss the human aspiration to explore stars, acknowledging the significant challenges due to the vast distances involved. Berendzen reflects on the historical context of space travel, pointing out that the moon missions were driven by Cold War politics and the desire to surpass Soviet achievements in space.

Art then brings up a recent astronomical discovery of a solar system similar to ours, located just over eight light years away. Berendzen explains the implications of this discovery, considering the time it would take to travel such a distance with current technology. He also touches on the cultural impact of human broadcast signals, humorously noting that television shows like “Ricky Lake” might be our unintentional interstellar emissaries. The discussion shifts to the possibility of detecting signals from extraterrestrial life, considering the age of our sun and the universe, and the likelihood of life evolving elsewhere at a similar pace to Earth.

Berendzen emphasizes that considering the enormous number of astronomical objects in the universe, it seems preposterous to assume that humans are the only intelligent beings. However, he acknowledges that even if life exists elsewhere, it may not have developed the ability to communicate beyond its planet. This leads to a discussion on the uniqueness of human evolution and the potential for intelligent life to exist without forming an industrial or scientific civilization.

They then move on to discuss recent astronomical discoveries, including the identification of planets orbiting stars similar to our sun. These discoveries raise the possibility of finding life on other planets. However, Berendzen notes the challenge in detecting such life, as the planets are much dimmer than their stars and hard to observe. He predicts that within the next couple of decades, we will have a better understanding of how common planetary systems are in the universe.

The conversation also touches on the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) program and the challenges it faces, such as determining which stars to observe and whether radio waves are the most effective means of interstellar communication. Berendzen speculates that future civilizations might consider our current reliance on radio waves as primitive, suggesting that other forms of communication, like gamma rays, could be used.

Berendzen explains the complexities involved in choosing the right time to listen for signals from space, emphasizing the vast time spans and distances involved. He suggests that Earth could have already received clear signals from intelligent beings in the past, but humanity was not technologically advanced enough to detect or understand them.

They delve into the technical aspects of radio astronomy, focusing on the importance of the 21-centimeter wavelength, which is related to hydrogen, the most abundant element in the universe. This wavelength is considered a natural beacon for communication due to its ubiquity. Berendzen highlights the efforts of the Harvard-funded SETI program, particularly the use of a billion-channel analyzer to scan various frequency bands.

The conversation shifts to the societal implications of contact with extraterrestrial intelligence. Art Bell brings up the Brookings Report, which speculated on the potentially destabilizing effects of such contact on human society. Berendzen expresses skepticism about these fears, arguing that it is impossible to predict how humanity would react to contact with a more advanced civilization. He also points out that extraterrestrial beings could be at various stages of advancement compared to humans, and the impact of contact would depend on this relative level of development.

Berendzen acknowledges that such encounters could range from benign to hostile, with possibilities including humans being observed, consumed, or even placed in a zoo by a more advanced civilization.

The conversation shifts to the topic of cosmic threats to Earth, particularly the dangers posed by comet impacts. Berendzen uses the example of Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9, which collided with Jupiter, to illustrate the catastrophic effects a similar event could have on Earth. He describes how such an impact could lead to acid rain, widespread fires, and tidal waves, potentially resulting in significant loss of life and environmental damage.

Berendzen also addresses the idea proposed in the Brookings Report about the potential societal upheaval that could result from contact with a more advanced extraterrestrial civilization. He expresses skepticism about the report’s predictions of anarchy and the loss of faith in scientific and religious paradigms, suggesting that it’s impossible to accurately predict humanity’s reaction to such an event.

The discussion then touches on the history of life on Earth, with Berendzen pondering the possibility that intelligent life, similar to humans, may have existed on Earth in different epochs. While he finds this idea intriguing, he notes the lack of compelling evidence to support such theories.

Berendzen discusses the concept that elements in our bodies were formed in the interiors of long-dead stars, illustrating the interconnectedness of all matter. He also touches on the formation of pre-biological molecules on early Earth, possibly leading to the emergence of life.

The conversation then shifts to cosmology and the Big Bang theory. Berendzen explains the idea that time and space began simultaneously with the Big Bang, challenging the common intuition that time has always existed. He emphasizes the link between space and time as described by Einstein, noting that before the Big Bang, there was no space and therefore no time. This leads to a philosophical discussion about the nature of the universe before the Big Bang, with Berendzen considering the role of a divine entity or supreme laws of nature.

Art Bell raises a query about recent astronomical findings that suggest the existence of stars older than the universe itself. Berendzen views this as an exciting paradox in astronomy and physics, potentially indicating that we are on the verge of a major scientific breakthrough. He suggests that either our understanding of the age of the universe, the age of stars, or the Big Bang theory itself could be incorrect.

Berendzen explains that the redshift observed in the universe suggests it is expanding, but this does not necessarily confirm the Big Bang. He mentions the alternative “steady state” model proposed by Fred Hoyle, which suggests the universe has always existed and matter is continuously created. However, Berendzen believes there is substantial evidence against this model, such as the distribution of quasars and the discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation, which are consistent with the Big Bang theory.

Art then asks Berendzen about the possibility of time travel and the predictions of Nostradamus. Berendzen expresses skepticism, arguing that the vague nature of such predictions allows them to be interpreted in many ways, often after the fact. He doubts that Nostradamus or others could genuinely see into the future.

The conversation shifts to the topic of ghosts, with Art inquiring about their existence from a physicist’s perspective. Berendzen suggests that this question might be better addressed by a psychiatrist or psychologist, as he has seen no scientific evidence supporting the existence of ghosts. He notes that physicists would be highly intrigued by concrete evidence of ghosts, but so far, no such evidence has been presented.

Berendzen explains that black holes, once formed, can continue to accumulate mass and become more massive. He cites the work of Stephen Hawking and Kip Thorne as significant contributions to our understanding of black holes. He mentions the possibility that the center of the Milky Way galaxy might contain a massive black hole and describes how remote quasars could be devouring mass at astonishing rates.

Berendzen then delves into the nature of black holes, describing them as entities collapsing out of the cosmos and compressing to incredibly small volumes. He notes that inside a black hole, the laws of physics as we understand them may no longer apply, which leads to many uncertainties and speculations about what occurs within these cosmic phenomena.

The conversation also touches on the concept of paired photons and the phenomenon of quantum entanglement. While Berendzen admits this is not his area of expertise, he acknowledges the theoretical realm of such concepts in physics, comparing it to the earlier skepticism and eventual acceptance of quarks in particle physics.

Lastly, Berendzen shares his personal experience with Carl Sagan, recalling how he was Sagan’s first teaching assistant at Harvard University. He describes Sagan’s ability to communicate science engagingly and accessibly and reminisces about their collaborative experiences, including interactions with Isaac Asimov.

Berendzen explains that while our current understanding of physics suggests we cannot travel faster than the speed of light, future space exploration might involve generational ships or cryogenics to enable long-duration voyages. He notes that our galaxy is actually about 100,000 light years across, far larger than previously mentioned, making interstellar travel an incredibly daunting task.

The conversation then shifts to Mars. Berendzen discusses evidence suggesting that Mars once had flowing water, citing images from the Viking spacecraft. He mentions upcoming robotic missions to Mars, including the first rover to land on another planet, named “Sojourner” after Sojourner Truth. This rover’s mission includes drilling into the Martian surface to investigate the possibility of a permafrost layer, which could hold significant implications for understanding the history of water on Mars and the potential for life.

Berendzen emphasizes the possibility of microbial life forms existing in Martian soil, drawing parallels to the abundance of microbial life in the harsh conditions of Antarctica on Earth. This exploration of Mars could lead to discoveries about primitive Martian chemistry or prebiotic conditions.

Berendzen explains the concept of comparative climatology, a field that has arisen from the exploration of other planets. He focuses on Venus, which, despite its similarities in size and mass to Earth, has experienced a runaway greenhouse effect, leading to its current extreme temperatures and dense atmosphere. This effect was triggered by the loss of water due to the planet’s proximity to the sun and subsequent atmospheric changes.

The conversation then turns to Earth’s climate. Berendzen discusses the concerns about the potential for a significant greenhouse effect on Earth, especially in light of industrialization and the emission of greenhouse gases. He emphasizes the need for caution and restraint in industrial activities to prevent environmental damage. The discussion touches on the political and philosophical aspects of this issue, with different viewpoints on the impact of human activities on the planet’s climate.

Additionally, they talk about recent reports of droughts in the Midwest and the possibility of these regions turning into deserts. Berendzen mentions chaos theory and its implications for understanding seemingly unpredictable phenomena like climate change. He advises against alarmism but acknowledges the importance of careful meteorological study and federal support for such research.

Berendzen explains that dramatic climatic changes have occurred on Earth throughout geological history, changing landscapes drastically over time. This conversation leads to speculations about Mars, where water once flowed, suggesting the possibility of primitive microbial life forms in its past. Berendzen discusses the theories surrounding Mars’ outflow channels and the likelihood that any water on the planet is now in a permanently frozen state beneath the surface.

The discussion then turns to the concept of terraforming – the idea of transforming a barren planet into one capable of supporting life. Berendzen notes the feasibility of such a project but raises questions about who would have the authority to undertake such a massive endeavor. He clarifies that no nation owns extraterrestrial objects by international law, even if they plant a flag, as the U.S. did on the Moon.

Berendzen reveals that NASA has detailed plans for building space colonies on Mars, the Moon, and asteroids, using indigenous materials to reduce the cost of transporting resources from Earth. He discusses the potential use of lunar soil to create water and the construction of habitats with their own atmospheres, a form of modified terraforming.

Additionally, Berendzen mentions the feasibility of using asteroids for space exploration, highlighting the U.S. spacecraft NEAR (Near-Earth Asteroid Rendezvous), which aims to study an asteroid closely. He addresses a caller’s question about hitching rides on asteroids or comets to gather data, acknowledging it as a good idea and a practical approach to studying these celestial objects.

Berendzen talks about the possibility of flying alongside a comet to study it throughout its entire course. He emphasizes the importance of studying near-Earth objects, such as comets and asteroids, due to their potential threat and contributions to life on Earth. He explains that some of the organic material in our bodies and even the water we drink likely originated from comets that fell to Earth.

The discussion then shifts to the idea of hitching a ride on a comet to gather data. Berendzen notes the challenges involved, especially with long-period comets that appear unexpectedly, making it difficult to plan missions in advance. He also mentions the recent detection of X-rays emitted by a comet, which was a surprising discovery, suggesting that the comet might not be a part of our solar system.

Next, Berendzen talks about Comet Hale-Bopp, which was visible at the time of the show. He provides information on how amateur astronomers can locate the comet and predicts it will be a spectacular sight in the coming months.

The conversation takes a fascinating turn into the realm of theoretical physics with the topic of miniature black holes. Berendzen discusses Stephen Hawking’s hypothesis about these tiny black holes, which could have formed during the Big Bang. He describes the potential effects if Earth were to encounter a miniature black hole, including gravitational perturbations and possible disruptions, although he notes that no evidence of such events has been detected.

Berendzen explains the intriguing nature of neutron stars, also known as pulsars, and their incredible density. He describes a hypothetical scenario where a piece of a neutron star, if brought to Earth, would crash through the planet due to its immense density.

They then discuss the rapid rotation of neutron stars and how they emit radio waves, akin to a lighthouse beam in space. The conversation shifts to comets, focusing on their structure and behavior as they approach the sun. Berendzen details how a comet’s nucleus, or its core, is typically a few miles in diameter, but as it nears the sun, it defrosts to form a coma and a long tail, dramatically increasing its size.

The discussion also covers Comet Hale-Bopp, which was visible at the time of the show. Berendzen predicts that Hale-Bopp could be more impressive than previous comets due to its size and activity. He emphasizes the significance of comets in the formation of planets and life, noting that they likely brought water and organic molecules to Earth.

Responding to a caller’s question, Berendzen talks about the possibility of comets breaking apart as they orbit the sun, either forming multiple comets or, in some cases, colliding with the sun. He concludes the segment by reflecting on the comet’s finite lifetime and the eventual demise of famous comets like Halley’s Comet.

In this segment of “Coast to Coast AM,” Art Bell transitions to a new guest, nuclear physicist Stanton Friedman, who brings a fresh perspective on extraterrestrial phenomena and UFOs. Friedman discusses his background in physics and his long-standing interest in UFOs, which began in 1958. He talks about his experience working on advanced, highly classified nuclear and space system development programs, and his transition to full-time speaking and UFO research in the 1970s.

Friedman shares his extensive experience in public speaking, having lectured at over 600 colleges and numerous professional groups across the United States and internationally. He highlights his role as the original investigator of the Roswell incident and mentions his upcoming book “Top Secret/Magic,” which delves into the Majestic 12 documents. These documents, according to Friedman, provide compelling evidence of the recovery of a crashed flying saucer with bodies in 1947 and the formation of a top-secret group, Majestic 12, accountable only to the President of the United States.

Friedman discusses his debate at the historic Oxford University Debating Society, where he successfully argued for the belief that intelligent alien life has visited Earth.

Friedman then delves into the misconceptions and lack of knowledge among journalists and the general public in England regarding UFOs and extraterrestrial phenomena. He expresses frustration at the widespread ignorance and fear of ridicule surrounding the topic, despite a significant portion of the population believing in the reality of UFOs.

The discussion shifts to the Roswell incident, which Friedman describes as one of the most attention-grabbing UFO cases. He emphasizes the unique position of Roswell Army Airfield as the only atomic bombing group in the world at the time and highlights the high security and caliber of the personnel involved. Friedman shares his interactions with key witnesses, including Colonel Thomas Jefferson Dubose, who played a crucial role in the cover-up of the incident.

Stanton Friedman recounts how he initially came across Major Jesse Marcel’s story in 1978 and how Marcel, the intelligence officer for the 509th Bomb Group at Roswell, had been misrepresented in various TV programs. Contrary to these portrayals, Friedman clarifies that he found Marcel through a chance conversation, leading to Marcel’s first public recounting of the Roswell event in over 30 years.

Friedman also shares another lead he followed, about a government employee who allegedly encountered a crashed flying saucer with bodies next to it in New Mexico. This information, combined with Marcel’s account, was crucial in the research that led to the first book about the Roswell incident, “The Roswell Incident,” published in 1989.

Friedman discusses the widespread media coverage of the Roswell incident in 1947, noting that it appeared in several major newspapers, not just the Roswell Daily Record. He emphasizes that the story resurfaced in the public eye due to his and others’ research, not because of sensationalist reporting by tabloids.

Friedman criticizes the Air Force’s handling of the Roswell case, pointing out inconsistencies and efforts to discredit witnesses and researchers. He firmly believes that the evidence overwhelmingly supports the occurrence of an extraordinary event at Roswell, involving the recovery of a crashed flying saucer.

Stanton Friedman addresses a piece of material given to the Roswell museum, noting its composition of copper and silver, common and dense elements. While he remains open-minded about this artifact, he lacks enough information to make a definitive assessment.

Friedman then recounts the story of Pappy Henderson, a pilot at Roswell Army Airfield, who claimed to have flown wreckage to Wright Patterson Air Force Base and mentioned seeing bodies. This testimony, corroborated by others who knew Henderson, adds to the intrigue surrounding Roswell.

The conversation shifts to the possibility of people having taken small pieces of debris from the crash site as souvenirs. Art Bell mentions that he received alleged crash pieces, which have undergone scientific examination. The results show anomalies in the aluminum and a layered structure of bismuth and magnesium in a piece purportedly from the spacecraft’s skin. Friedman finds this combination of materials, especially in a layered structure, to be quite remarkable and not something typical of earthly origins.

Friedman emphasizes that the discovery of extraterrestrial materials would not simply involve finding elements not from Earth. Instead, it’s the unique combination and structure of these materials that make them potentially significant.

Stanton Friedman begins by analyzing a piece that was given to the Roswell Museum, noting its composition of common elements like copper and silver. Without a clear provenance, Friedman remains cautious, placing it in his “gray basket” of uncertainty.

Friedman then delves into more intriguing material, specifically discussing a layered bismuth and magnesium piece. He finds this combination peculiar, especially given the complexity of creating such layered structures. The material’s unusual properties raise questions about its origin and potential applications, particularly in the context of electromagnetic systems or heat protection in aerospace technology.

Art Bell mentions the electron scanning microscope photographs of the aluminum pieces, which show embedded sand, indicating a high-impact event. This detail adds to the mystery and suggests that the material underwent significant stress or heating.

Friedman also addresses the challenge of differentiating between earthly and extraterrestrial materials. He points out that the presence of known elements doesn’t necessarily point to an earthly origin, as the same elements are found throughout the galaxy. The key lies in the unique combination and manufacturing techniques that might be employed for extraterrestrial purposes.

Art Bell and Stanton Friedman discuss the complexities of analyzing materials purportedly related to UFOs and the Roswell incident. They talk about a particular piece of material given to the Roswell Museum and the challenges involved in authenticating such artifacts.

Friedman explains that forensic testing of potential UFO materials needs to be rigorous, comparable to what would be used in a court of law. He also mentions the difficulties in identifying extraterrestrial materials, as the same elements found on Earth are also present throughout the galaxy. The uniqueness would lie in their manufacturing techniques or combinations.

They discuss a specific artifact made of layered bismuth and magnesium. This material has drawn attention due to its unusual properties and the complexity of its layered structure. However, Friedman emphasizes the importance of provenance in establishing the authenticity of such artifacts. Knowing the original source or the context of how the material was obtained could significantly bolster its credibility.

Friedman and Bell also discuss the funding challenges for scientific analysis in UFO research. They appeal to the source of the materials to provide more information, which could help in verifying the artifacts’ authenticity and potentially attract funding for further testing.

Art Bell and Stanton Friedman discuss a recent alleged UFO incident in Brazil, known as the “Varginha Case.” Friedman explains that he was in Brazil for a conference and had the opportunity to investigate the incident, which involved the capture of alien beings.

Friedman describes the details of the incident, which reportedly occurred in Varginha, Brazil. He talks about interviewing key individuals involved in the investigation, including a team of researchers and John Mack, a well-known figure in UFO research. The story, as recounted by witnesses and researchers, involves the recovery of several alien bodies described as short, with big heads, skinny bodies, oily brown skin, large red eyes, and no apparent clothing or genitals.

The initial report of the incident came from three young ladies who encountered the creatures. Friedman mentions that the local fire department was involved in capturing these beings, as they are responsible for dealing with unusual animals or situations in Brazil.

He describes the initial sighting of the creature by three young girls who thought it might be a statue or even the devil due to its strange appearance, with red eyes and bumps on the head. Their reaction prompted local authorities, including the fire department, to capture the being. The story further involves other sightings, including a possible UFO resembling a submarine shape, witnessed moving over a farmer’s field.

Friedman mentions the involvement of the Brazilian military and the police in the incident. He also refers to potential bribery attempts to silence witnesses and hints at possible U.S. government involvement. The complexity of the case is heightened by reports of multiple alien beings and possibly a crashed spacecraft. He notes the challenges in linking the beings to a specific craft and the need for more evidence to establish a stronger connection between the two.

Friedman is cautiously optimistic about the potential for more information to emerge, given the recent nature of the event and the ongoing investigation. He also notes the positive attitude of the Brazilian press towards the incident, contrasting it with the lack of significant coverage in the American press.

Stanton Friedman recounts the girls’ initial encounter with an alien creature, describing their shock and fear. The creature was crouched down, had bumps on the head, large feet, and red eyes, leading one of the girls to think it might be the devil. The girls’ reaction led to the involvement of the local fire department, which eventually captured the being.

Friedman goes on to describe other aspects of the incident, including a saucer-shaped object moving over a farmer’s field, military involvement, and the potential transfer of an alien being to the United States. He mentions that several witnesses reported the creature to be in a state of distress or shock.

The story also involves reports of trucks filled with shiny wreckage and a possible cover-up effort. Friedman notes that while there are many strands to the story, a direct connection between the alien beings and a craft has not yet been established. He emphasizes the need for more evidence to solidify this link.

Friedman offers to provide a two-page report on the Varginha case to interested listeners who send a self-addressed stamped envelope to his address. He emphasizes his commitment to spreading factual information about UFO incidents.

Stanton Friedman addresses rumors about the Greys allegedly working with the U.S. government, stating that while he’s heard these claims, he has yet to see convincing evidence to support them. Friedman also discusses Bob Lazar, expressing skepticism about Lazar’s claims and qualifications.

Friedman then shifts to the controversial “Alien Autopsy” film. He recounts his meetings with Ray Santilli, the film’s promoter, and expresses doubts about the film’s authenticity. Friedman notes inconsistencies in Santilli’s story, including the alleged photographer’s identity and the film’s supposed connection to President Harry Truman. He emphasizes the improbability of a cameraman being able to keep top-secret footage from 1947, given the strict handling of classified materials.

Friedman talks about the “Alien Autopsy” film and expresses skepticism about its authenticity. Friedman notes that he has found inconsistencies and untruths in the claims made by Ray Santilli, the film’s promoter. Despite initially being open to the possibility of the film being genuine, Friedman’s investigations have led him to doubt its veracity.

The conversation shifts to listener calls. One caller from Los Angeles recounts a UFO sighting and asks about the appearance of the materials Friedman received, specifically if they were dull or shiny. Friedman confirms that the bismuth and magnesium materials he discussed earlier were shiny on one side.

Another caller inquires about obtaining more information on the Varginha incident in Brazil. Friedman provides the name and address of a Brazilian magazine that featured an extensive article on the incident, suggesting it as a resource for further information.

Friedman also addresses a question about the “common sense theory of time,” although the caller is unable to articulate the theory fully. Another caller shares an observation related to the Brazil incident, further highlighting public interest in UFO sightings and encounters.

One caller shares an observation of a containment unit being transported, potentially related to UFO activity, but without concrete evidence. Another caller inquires about the current status of Area 51 and whether it remains a hotspot for UFO activity. Friedman suggests that while Area 51 has received a lot of attention, much of the advanced technology testing might have moved to more remote areas. He explains that the site was used for testing advanced propulsion systems and other sophisticated technologies, and that the presence of drones or UAVs (uninhabited aerial vehicles) might explain some UFO sightings in the area.

A caller then asks about the feasibility of achieving hyper speeds of 35,000 to 40,000 miles per hour using rotating electromagnetic fields as a propulsion system. Friedman is skeptical about the velocity claims but acknowledges the potential of magneto-aerodynamic propulsion systems, which he has written about since the late 1960s. He mentions ongoing research in this field, suggesting it could be a promising direction for future propulsion technology.

Friedman encourages listeners to stay informed and critical about UFO claims and evidence. He agrees to stay in touch with the host, Art Bell, regarding the materials they discussed and upcoming shows.